23.1.13

The Marinière Experiment

Marinières: Comme des Garçons, Saint James

Among the inspirational pictures I gathered when I started editing my wardrobe, I noticed a recurring element: breton shirts, or marinières. How do you translate inspirations into your own style? In this case, I decided to use the benefit of low priced offerings to make a little experiment.

When I started style searching, figuring out what I liked was the easy part, you only need to find inspirational outfits. The hard part was to find what element of each outfit inspired me exactly, and how to integrate it into my personal style. I already explained one method I used to find out some of these ingredients. With the marinière, here is another one that worked for me.

My earliest most recurring purchase mistakes were to buy something I saw in a picture I liked, only to realize I didn't feel comfortable wearing it, because it didn't fit my silhouette or I didn't like the way I was pairing it. Since I favour quality over quantity, that kind of mistake was costly.

After about a year of style searching, here is a method I decided to apply before investing in a new basic, staple or expensive garment. I used it to find out many of my current staples, and rule out some elements that were best admired from afar.

The first step of this method is to identify a recurring element in my inspirations, by trying to find themes or common elements to my inspirational picture folder. Here, a marinière themed selection.

Sources: Comptoir des Cotonniers, tumblr

Then, the second step is to figure out how this translates into my style. For this, I'd to the five outfits exercise, a.k.a imagine five different outfits featuring a breton shirt and existing pieces from my closet.

1. Casual elegant: with denim, suede ankle boots and a blazer
2. Relaxed: With hooded cardigan, jeans and Converse
3. Traveler: With black pants, suede leather jacket and oxfords
4. Summer: With light grey shorts and brown sandals
5. Evening: with black pants, ballet flats and golden jewerly

Third step: the experiment part. Instead of investing straight away in quality breton shirts, I have decided to start off with a simple, low cost one. I settled for a black and white even stripes one from Muji, to actually try it out in real life. There is no other way to know if you're going to be comfortable wearing something unless you actually do, for a full day and not five minutes in a shop.

Finally, if the experiment is a success, meaning if I wore the cheap test garment a lot and felt good in it, it's time for the real purchase, the qualitative one. In my case, it wasn't hard to decide. I wore my Muji breton shirt so often it fell apart in less than six months.

A little recap of the marinière experiment:
  • Identify a recurring element among your sources of inspiration
  • Imagine five outfits featuring elements of your closets and this new element
  • Purchase a low cost version of this element to try it out for a few months
  • If this is a success, invest in a quality piece
  • Create a new staple of yours by integrating related garments over time

I settled for a high quality version of the same marinière: black and white, even stripes, from Comme des Garçons. After a few months, I completed it with a more classical one, a cream and navy one from Saint James.

These two have become part of my core wardrobe, I wear them at least than once a week each. On the first picture above, I was on holidays in Alsace wearing the Comme des Garçons in the "casual elegant" outfit, with light blue denim, black blazer and chocolate brown ankle boots.

Now that I know marinière is one of my signatures, next time one of my tops wears out, I might as well look for a marinière in a similar colour as a replacement...

15 comments:

  1. I love marineres and am actually surviving on an old Muji one from 2009, and a newer one from Gap in 2010. They look a little worse for wear now but I'm too lazy to go find new ones.

    I admire how systematic you are about dressing! I think the low cost experiment is a good one. I bought a pair of chukka boots from Topshop in 2011 and love them, and now that a hole has appeared I'm more prepared to invest in a better-made pair.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're lucky that both your marinières have survived the years! I must admit I would have liked my Muji one to last a bit longer, even if I didn't pay a lot for it, it kinda felt like a waste to throw it away so quickly.

      I see what you mean with being lazy to find new ones. It's so annoying to go hunting for a particular piece, especially if you have very specific taste. I know I do, and sometimes I'd rather let go than waste my time running around town to find something.

      Delete
  2. That's such a great idea! I do the same thing with trendier pieces, to decide if I like it enough to buy a more quality one so I can wear it after the trend fades. I always love seeing the process behind your closet!


    http://www.erindepew.com/blog

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That can be a good one too! I usually do it with a basic, but it can be a way to test how more original pieces endure time...

      Delete
  3. Oh, and I forgot to mention that I totally agree with needing to try out a piece in four or five different situations. I do a similar (although with less classic pieces!) exercise in my style remix series:

    http://www.erindepew.com/blog/category/style-remix/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. and thanks for sharing! I've browsed your blog and I really like it, especially your "two cent thoughts" series :)

      Delete
  4. As I wrote in your earlier post my breton shirts are currently from H&M and Monki and not of very good quality. You've got a point about the the cheaper items being "test spins" though - they've made me more aware of which cuts and fabrics I would like to get when I do invest in the future! The Comme des Garçons one looks so soft and lovely :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes the Comme des Garçons marinière is very comfortable, while being quite sturdy. The Muji one basically lost its shape so I wanted a fabric that looked solid, and when I first saw the CdG one it seemed just perfect.

      I must admit that, although it looks easy on the blog post afterwards, in real life I took quite some time to make a decision. This is not a price range i'm used to at all... That's why I got the second one from Saint James, more affordable if not cheap :)

      Delete
  5. I absolutely adore breton striped tops, and have amassed a small collection which I tend to wear on a regular basis. I did have the Commes one, but I chose to let it go because I wasn't too keen on the fit.

    I like your process for investing though, it's pretty much how I've gone about buying white skinny jeans. I'm at the point where I would be happy to invest in a more expensive pair (the ones I have stretch out a lot with wear)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If you really wear your white skinny jeans often, you definitely should invest in a higher quality pair! I tend to think the more you wear something, the more it is worth the investment, to a certain degree of course.

      It is true the fit of the CdG marinière is quite unusual, it fits quite closely to the body and the neckline is high. Maybe purchasing a larger size changes the fit a little though...

      Delete
  6. I adore breton shirts and have amassed a small collection of them. I consider them to be classics and I never get tired of them.

    I've considered the Comme shirt, but was on the fence about it. I've seen a few things by them that haven't blown me away quality wise- like their cashmere sweaters.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Breton shirts definitely are timeless! If you have any brand/store suggestions to expand a little my collection, please let me know, you have always such good advice.

      I didn't know comme des Garçons at all when I purchased the shirt so I guess I'll form my opinion on this product at least. To be honest I found it a bit expensive, but the fabric, cut and colour were exactly what I was looking for so I decided to take a chance, successfully so far.

      Delete
  7. Like everyone here I also adore Breton shirts. I have one from Topshop that I've worn for 4 years, I absolutely love it, I've worn it with so many different combinations that it's one of my basics. Too bad, now it looks pretty ugly and has some mysterious holes that I've mended but I can see that it won't last another season of serious wearing.

    So I've been considering investing on a Saint James for a long time (yeah my budget is that low that I have to 'invest' on Saint James, lol) but I'm terrified about the fit since in Chile there is no place where I can try one. I'm normally a size 8-10 (UK size) for tops. May I ask which size you got? According to the website I would be a 36 and from your pic, it seems we have a similar size or at least you can give me a hint on the fit.
    There was also one mariniere in red from Petit Bateau that I absolutely loved but first I need one like the blue/ecru Saint James, ahhh priorities!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's already great that your Topshop one lasted for 4 years! Apart from my Muji coat I don't think any of my high street garments have lasted more than one or two years, so you got great value out of it!

      My Saint James breton shirt is a 36 indeed, I think it's the smallest women's size. But it is the 95% cotton 5% elasthane one (I don't remember its name). It fits right on the body, not too sticky nor too loose. One of them is made of polyester though and I remember when I tried it on it was too much sticking to the body to my taste, so be careful which model you get, depending on what kind of fit you want.

      Delete
    2. Thanks for your reply! I'll keep an eye on the composition of the tshirts, I'm looking for one called miniquiers, now I gotta find a shop that sends to my country (cross my fingers!).

      Delete